The best mystery movies make you feel smart for figuring it out, or stunned that you didn't. Either way, audiences know when a mystery delivers. Critics tend to overthink the puzzle and miss the fun.
Peacock has a growing catalog that's worth exploring, especially if you've already burned through Netflix and Max. Their mystery selection has some unexpected gems.
These are the mysteries that kept real viewers guessing — and satisfied them with the answer.
Every movie on this list is ranked by ThumbScore — the percentage of everyday people who liked the film. No critic gatekeeping, no algorithmic manipulation. Just real audience verdicts.